top of page

One word is not enough to judge schools, so why is this system still used to rate care homes?

Sarah Whitebloom

It is impossible to paint a picture of a school in one word, according to the Department of Education, which has scrapped this process of delivering judgement. One word was simply not working for parents and children, according to the DofE's statement. So why is the system still being used for care homes - where the most vulnerable members of society live 24 hours a day?


The Care Quality Commission's care home rating system was based on Ofsted's discredited one word process but it has, remarkably, not been abandoned.


OLM has long argued this is a useless way to rate care homes, since the single words are based on snapshot inspections which can be out of date before the ink is dry. Or, as is regularly the case, they are just completely wrong because care homes are effective at putting on a good show.


And, unlike most schools, many care homes have wealthy and powerful owners, who come armed with teams of lawyers at any hint of a poor rating from the CQC. This all goes, perhaps, to explain why so many homes are rated highly, despite evidence to the contrary.


The DofE said: "We want parents to have access to a much more complete picture of how schools are performing, well beyond a single word....We also want higher standards..."


Older and vulnerable people also deserve more - and better.

What is happening when you are not there?


 
 
 

Comments


© 2017 by OlderLivingMatters   All text and original photos subject to copyright                  

OlderLivingMatters is a journalistic website offering information, guidance and advice based on experience of life today for older people. It is designed to be a friendly hand in difficulties and to highlight the problems of older people and their families. As with any friend, it is not perfect and will not have all the answers all of the time. Everyone’s situation is different and this needs to be taken this into account if you take action. Please be aware that you use the information and advice on this website at your own risk and it is not responsible or liable if things go wrong.  

bottom of page